Consistency Is the Real Test of Leadership Team Standards
In this October article we explore how leadership teams maintain their agreed standards, particularly when the pressure is on.

In my first October article, Your Organisation Is Watching the Leadership Team, I explored how the behaviours, symbols and systems of an Executive Leadership Team (ELT) influence the culture of the broader organisation. But there is another important dimension to this.
Setting expectations is one thing. Consistently living them is another.
When I work with leadership teams, we often spend time discussing what it means to be a high-performing team. We explore the behaviours they want to demonstrate, how they will work together, and what they should expect from one another.
These are valuable conversations, and teams are usually very clear about what good looks like.
They want to demonstrate trust, accountability, constructive challenge, collaboration and respect.
The challenge is rarely knowing what to do.
The real challenge is doing it consistently, particularly when things get difficult.
It's Easy to Agree When Things Are Going Well
Think about the expectations commonly agreed upon by leadership teams.
We will challenge each other constructively.
We will make decisions together and support them once made.
We will hold each other accountable.
We will operate as enterprise leaders, rather than focusing solely on our individual functions.
All good intentions.
But what happens when a difficult decision affects your area of responsibility? When a colleague doesn't deliver on a commitment? When the CEO makes a decision you disagree with? Or when the organisation is under significant pressure to deliver results?
Suddenly, those agreed behaviours can become harder to demonstrate.
We might avoid a difficult conversation, revisit a decision outside the meeting room, or focus on protecting our own team rather than considering what is best for the organisation.
Pressure doesn't remove the need for agreed behaviours. It makes them even more important.
When the Pressure Is On
Every leadership team experiences periods of pressure. Competing priorities, financial challenges, organisational change, limited resources and unexpected events are all part of leading an organisation.
During these times, it can be tempting to put the team's agreed Ways of Working to one side and focus entirely on getting things done.
Meetings become more transactional. Communication becomes less open. Decisions are made by a few rather than through constructive discussion. Leaders retreat into their functional responsibilities.
And sometimes, behaviours that would normally be challenged are overlooked because everyone is busy.
But these are precisely the moments when the organisation is paying attention.
People notice when leaders stop collaborating, when decisions are inconsistent, or when accountability seems to depend on who is involved.
The standards we demonstrate under pressure often speak louder than the standards we agree upon when things are calm.
Holding Each Other to the Standard
One of the most important shifts in a high-performing leadership team is moving from relying on the CEO to maintain standards, to every team member taking responsibility.
This means being prepared to call each other back to the behaviours and commitments the team has agreed upon.
Not through criticism or blame, but through genuine care for the team and its collective performance.
It might be as simple as saying:
"I thought we had agreed to challenge each other in the room. Can we revisit that conversation?"
"Are we making this decision from an enterprise perspective, or are we protecting our individual areas?"
"We committed to supporting this decision. What has changed?"
These conversations require trust, courage and a willingness to be challenged ourselves. And they are not always comfortable.
However, when team members can respectfully challenge one another, acknowledge when they have fallen short, and make adjustments without becoming defensive, something important happens.
Accountability becomes a shared responsibility, rather than something driven by the CEO.
This is when a leadership team starts to demonstrate genuine collective leadership.
How Much Do We Really Want to Be Better?
One of the challenges I regularly see when working with leadership teams is the gap between the commitments made during a team coaching session and what happens in the weeks that follow.
Teams have constructive conversations, agree on their Ways of Working and genuinely commit to becoming more effective. Yet within a matter of weeks, familiar behaviours begin to return.
Not necessarily because the commitment wasn't genuine, but because changing established behaviours is hard. People are busy, the demands of the business continue, and it is easier to fall back into familiar ways of operating.
Often, the expectation is that the CEO will remind people of their commitments and hold them accountable.
But surely that's not what collective leadership is about?
If everyone owns the team's performance, everyone must take responsibility for maintaining its standards.
And this leads me to a question I think every leadership team needs to ask itself.
How much do we really want to become a high-performing team, and what are we prepared to do differently to achieve it?
Because wanting to be better and being prepared to change are not always the same thing.
Consistency Builds Trust and Credibility
Trust isn't built simply because a leadership team has agreed on a set of behaviours.
It develops through repeated experiences of those behaviours being demonstrated.
When people see their leaders following through on commitments, making decisions that align with stated priorities, and treating one another with respect even during disagreements, confidence grows.
They begin to trust that what leaders say is what they will do.
Equally, inconsistency can quickly undermine credibility.
If collaboration is encouraged but siloed behaviour is tolerated, people notice. If accountability is promoted but some leaders are repeatedly excused from their commitments, people notice. If openness is valued but challenging conversations are shut down when they become uncomfortable, people notice.
And these observations shape how people behave across the organisation.
Consistency gives credibility to our words. Inconsistency creates doubt.
This doesn't mean leadership teams will always get it right. They won't.
What matters is whether they recognise when they have drifted away from their agreed standards and are prepared to address it.
Sometimes the most powerful example a leadership team can set is acknowledging that it hasn't lived up to its own expectations, and demonstrating what it will do differently.
Keeping the Standards Alive
A leadership team's Ways of Working should not be something agreed at a workshop, documented and then forgotten. They need to become part of how the team operates every day.
This means regularly reflecting on how effectively the team is working together, revisiting commitments when challenges emerge, and making space to discuss behaviours as well as business outcomes.
Importantly, these conversations shouldn't only happen when something has gone wrong. Recognising when colleagues demonstrate the agreed behaviours is just as valuable as challenging them when they don't.
Over time, these small, consistent actions reinforce what the team stands for.
A Question for Your Leadership Team
At your next leadership team meeting, consider:
Which of our agreed behaviours are we consistently demonstrating, even when under pressure?
Where have we allowed standards to slip, and what has stopped us from addressing this?
How much do we really want to become a high-performing team, and what are we prepared to change?
And perhaps the most challenging question of all:
"If the CEO doesn't intervene, who in this team will have the courage to call out behaviour that doesn't meet our agreed standards?"
Because if everyone is waiting for someone else to take responsibility, nothing will change. Agreeing on how a team wants to operate is only the beginning. The real work is maintaining those standards through the everyday challenges of leading an organisation.
Your organisation is still watching.
The question is no longer just what standards you set, but whether you consistently live them.




Comments